The FlintoftsA story from the Flintoft family archive

The Daghestan: Life of a Tramp Steamer, 1911 to 1951

HISTORICAL SKETCH

A note before reading

HISTORICAL SKETCH. Every date, name, place, tonnage and quotation here comes from a record in the Flintoft History project or from period sources checked for this piece. Where the narrator imagines (a smell, a sky, a thought), the passage is set in italics and should be read as colour, not evidence. Myths and legends of the places she sailed are told as myths and legends, clearly named, to set the iron and coal of her working life against the stories of the waters she worked in. Daily life aboard comes from period law, pay rates and accounts of ships like her, not from her own crew lists, which are not yet seen. This piece never flows back into the family tree.

The voice. Hawthorne opened The Scarlet Letter with a man rummaging in a custom house who finds a faded bundle of papers and is haunted into telling its story. That device fits us exactly, because this whole history began with a folder. So the prologue borrows Hawthorne. The rest borrows the marine essayists who wrote while the Daghestan was afloat, above all Joseph Conrad in The Mirror of the Sea (1906): long, unhurried sentences that know the weight of coal and the temper of weather, but stay plain enough to read on a phone. Imagine a narrator of today with all her papers spread across a table, telling it in an older voice.

Prologue: The Folder

There is, in the archive of Lloyd's Register, a folder of heavy paper that has been opened and shut so many times its spine has gone soft as cloth. On its face, in a surveyor's square capitals, someone has written DAGHESTAN, and below that, Messrs Short Bros, and below that, Profile and Deck Plan, No. 373 and 375. Purple stamps crowd the margin like the visas in an old passport: 25 July 1911, 11 September 1911, 25 November 1911, 31 January 1912, and so on into the April of that year, each one a day on which some clerk in London received a drawing, looked at it, and passed it on.

Inside lies a blueprint. It is the colour of deep water, and on it, in lines of white, a ship lies on her side with her secrets drawn open: the long holds, the boilers, the shaft tunnel running aft to the screw, the little cabins under the bridge where men slept. She has no name on the drawing, only a number. Two ships were built from it. One was sunk by a German submarine in 1917 and has been at the bottom of the Atlantic ever since. The other was the Daghestan, and she lived for thirty-nine years, carried eight names, flew three flags, saved some hundred and eighty lives on a night when the sea itself was on fire, was bombed and sunk in one war and raised to sail in the peace after it, and at last went down quietly in the North Atlantic, watched by her own crew from a stranger's deck.

Among all the people who ever walked her decks, one interests us more than the rest. He was fourteen when he joined her, the youngest son of a London gas clerk, and he would carry her with him to the other side of the world and tell his grandson about her for the rest of his life. The grandson, a long time later, wanted to know whether the stories were true. That wanting is how this folder came to be opened again.

It is a strange thing to hold the plan of a ship that no longer exists. One half expects the paper to be wet.

I. The Yard at Pallion

In 1911 the River Wear was less a river than a long, smoking workshop. From the bridges at Sunderland down to the sea, both banks were lined with berths and cranes, and the town liked to call itself the greatest shipbuilding town in the world. The ships it made were not the famous ones. They were tramps: plain, deep-bellied steamers that went wherever a cargo waited and a freight could be earned, coal out and grain or ore home, built by the dozen for owners who counted every shilling.

It was an old river for such new work. Near its mouth, a mile or two below the Pallion yard, stands the tower of St Peter's church at Monkwearmouth, raised in the 670s, where a boy called Bede was given to the monks at the age of seven. The town may owe its name to him. Bede wrote that he was born in the sundorland of the monastery, its land set apart, and Sunderland is very probably that old word: the estate set apart for the monks of Wearmouth. The Wear itself is older still, a British river name whose meaning is uncertain; the likeliest guess is a bend. Bede grew up to be the first great English historian, and among other things he worked out, from watching this coast, that the tides follow the moon and run later at one harbour than the next. Twelve hundred years on, the men building ships on his river still timed their launches by the tides he had studied.

Short Brothers had been part of that river since 1850, when George Short began building small wooden ships upstream at Hylton. By the new century the firm had moved down to Pallion, gone over to iron and then steel, and become a limited company employing about fifteen hundred men. Its yard numbers ran into the hundreds. Number 373 and number 375 were ordered by the same Newcastle owners, to the same drawings, and the clerks at Lloyd's stamped the plans for both.

The drawings carried a phrase that mattered: Isherwood System (Patent). For centuries ships had been built like the skeleton of a fish, with ribs, or frames, rising at intervals from the keel. Joseph Isherwood, a grocer's son from Hartlepool who had become a Lloyd's surveyor, had worked out that a steel hull could be stronger and lighter if most of its framing ran lengthways instead, with deep transverse webs at intervals to hold the shape. He patented it in 1906, and the first ship built to it went to sea in 1908. When the Daghestan's frames went up, the idea was barely four years old. Her owners were buying something modern.

The Lloyd's surveyor at Sunderland came to inspect her for the first time on 24 January 1912, and from then until the end of August he came back again and again, his visits jotted on the report form in a cramped column of dates: January, February, March, April, May, June, July, almost every working week. He checked the rivets, so many to a butt, spaced so many diameters apart. He tested the double bottom, the tanks that would carry 1,116 tons of water ballast when she ran light. He noted the thickness of the plates, sheet by sheet, from the keel up to the sheer strake.

Picture the noise of it. A riveting gang of four, a boy heating rivets in a brazier and tossing them glowing up to the catcher, the holder-up bracing on the inside, the riveter hammering the hot iron flat. Multiply that by every berth on the river. Men went deaf in those yards and thought nothing of it.

She went into the water on 19 July 1912, three months after the Titanic had gone down in the Atlantic and the whole maritime world was talking about lifeboats. On paper she measured 346 feet 4 inches long and 50 feet 6 inches in the beam, 3,691 gross tons, with a triple-expansion engine that would drive her at a little over eight knots when loaded. She had four hatches, two masts rigged as a schooner, one tall funnel amidships, and four boats: two lifeboats, a cutter and a dinghy. Remember the boats. They will matter more than anything else about her.

On 10 September 1912 the committee in London assigned her the class +100 A1, the mark of a sound ship. The surveyor's last line read that the materials and workmanship were good. Her first destination was the Bristol Channel, where the Welsh coal waited.

II. The House of Common

Her owners were the Hindustan Steam Shipping Company, founded in 1893 and managed by Common Brothers, a Tyneside family firm that would go on running ships for almost ninety years. The Commons had a habit, as shipowners do, of naming their vessels to a pattern, and theirs was the far edges of Asia: Hindustan, Daghestan, Kurdistan. Daghestan was a land of mountains on the western shore of the Caspian, then a province of the Russian Empire. It is unlikely that any of the men who sailed in her ever saw it. The name was a promise of distance painted on the stern of a coal boat.

The real Dagestan was older and stranger than any shipowner's chart. The name means "land of mountains", from the Turkic dağ, mountain, and the Persian -stan, land. Its coast is a narrow strip between the high Caucasus and the Caspian, and at its narrowest point stands Derbent, whose name is Persian for "closed gate". Derbent claims to be the oldest city in Russia. Its stone walls, about thirty metres high, were built by the Persian kings of the sixth century to bar the gap between mountain and sea, and medieval legend made it the Gate of Alexander, the wall that Alexander the Great built to hold back the wild peoples of the north. The Arabs took it in 654 and brought Islam. Persia ceded it to Russia in 1813. In the mountains behind, more than thirty peoples speaking more than thirty languages held out against the tsars for a generation under the imam Shamil, until he surrendered on Mount Gunib in August 1859 and was sent into exile at Kaluga, south of Moscow. Tolstoy's novella of that war, Hadji Murat, was first published in 1912, the year the Daghestan was launched. Whether anyone at Common Brothers knew any of this when they had the name painted on her stern, no one can say.

The tramp trade had its own geography, and the Daghestan learned it quickly. Out from Barry, Cardiff or Port Talbot, low in the water with Welsh steam coal, the best in the world for raising steam. Down past Ushant and across the Bay of Biscay, past Gibraltar and into the Mediterranean, to Italy, Sicily, Algeria, wherever the coal was wanted. Then in ballast, light and rolling, to the ore piers of southern Spain or North Africa, where iron ore poured into her holds from chutes, and home again to the steelworks of South Wales and the north. A voyage was not a timetable. It was a chain of bargains struck by brokers in London, and the ship went where the next freight was.

It was a road paved with old stories. The Bay of Biscay, where the long Atlantic swell meets the shelf of France and piles up into the steepest seas a deep-laden tramp would ever meet, had a reputation among sailors that no amount of steam could improve. Then Gibraltar, the Rock the ancients called Calpe, one of the two Pillars of Hercules that marked the end of the known world. Later legend said the pillars bore a warning, non plus ultra, nothing further beyond. The Daghestan passed between them going the other way, into the oldest sea of all, with a hold full of Welsh coal.

Her master was John Macfarlane. The 1912 survey records that he had been in the owners' service since 1909 and took command of the Daghestan when she was new. He would keep her for seven years, through everything that followed, and the record shows nothing of him that is not steady. Crew lists from 1915 name two of his apprentices: Alfred John Norris, indentured at Barry in 1911, and Frank Defty, a Sunderland boy indentured in 1912. They are the earliest of the Daghestan's boys we can name. A few years later Macfarlane would write to a London clerk about two more.

We know more of Macfarlane than of any other man who sailed in her. The 1915 crew lists give his age as 40 and his birthplace as Glenluce, in Wigtownshire, a village on Luce Bay in the far south-west corner of Scotland, near the ruins of a Cistercian abbey. Galloway sent its sons to sea for generations, and he was one of them. He would have been born about 1874 or 1875. He joined the Hindustan company's service in 1909, took the new Daghestan out of Sunderland in 1912, and kept her through the sale to the Rome company, the war, probably the Brescia collision of 1917, the Chaouia rescue of 1919, a French silver-gilt medal and a presentation in May 1919. He knew the Flintofts well enough to write to Thomas Flintoft about his sons, and to wish that one would do as well as the other. Late in 1919 Charles Lenton took command, and what became of Macfarlane after that has not yet been traced. His master's certificate, and the Lloyd's Captains' Registers, would tell the rest. (Birthplace, age, service and command DOCUMENTED; birth year PROBABLE from his age; his later life not yet researched.)

Her sister went first. The Hindustan, yard number 373, was surveyed in June 1912, a month ahead of her, and the two ships were twins down to the rivet spacing. The surveyor at Sunderland noted it in the margin of the Daghestan's report: this vessel is a duplicate of the S.S. Hindustan. On 21 March 1917 the German submarine U 46 torpedoed the Hindustan about 150 miles west-north-west of the Fastnet, on passage from Beaumont in Texas to Queenstown and two of her men died. Six months later another Common ship from the same yard, the Kurdistan, was sunk off Pantelleria with a cargo of coal for Alexandria. The family of ships was being worn away.

Somewhere in her early years there must have been a morning when she came into Barry for the first time and the coal tips swung over her, and the black dust settled on everything, the brass, the paintwork, the men's faces and the white of their eyes. It was the smell of her trade, and she would carry it all her life.

War came in August 1914. Lloyd's Register for that winter still shows her as the Hindustan company's ship, registered at Sunderland, Macfarlane in command. By the edition of 1917 to 1918 she had been sold, and she belonged to Italy's war.

Interlude: A Day Aboard

No crew list for the Daghestan in Jack's time has yet been read. But her crew lists of 1915, three years before he joined, survive at Greenwich, and they show what kind of company he joined: about thirty men to a voyage. They lived in two worlds that met only at meals and in port.

They came from everywhere. On her three 1915 agreements, under the Scottish master, there are mates and engineers from Sunderland, South Shields, Hull, Gateshead and Longhope in Orkney, a boatswain from Kinsale and another from Shetland, a carpenter from Tonsberg in Norway and another from Durban. Her seamen came from London, Liverpool and Tunbridge Wells, but also from Antwerp, Stockholm, Reval and Russia, and three teenage sailors had come off the same Newcastle ship from Norway and Denmark. Her firemen and trimmers were from Cork, Seaham and Glasgow, Arendal, Odense, Malmo and Gothenburg, from Amsterdam and Berne, two Greeks, an Egyptian, and two young men from Dominica in the West Indies. Her mess-room steward on one voyage was from Johor, in Malaya. The youngest was 18 and the oldest 62. A British tramp in the age of empire was a small floating world, and a London boy of fourteen would have heard half a dozen languages in his first week aboard. Of her two 1915 apprentices, one, Alfred Norris, appears on a later agreement that same year as her third mate, at 21. That was the road Jack's indentures promised him.

Up top lived the master, three mates, the boatswain and carpenter, a handful of able and ordinary seamen, the cook and steward, a mess boy, and the apprentices. Their day was ruled by the watch. Four hours on, eight off, round the clock: the middle watch from midnight to four, the morning watch to eight, and so on through the day, with the two short dog watches in the evening so that no man stood the same hours every night. The bell on the bridge struck every half-hour, one stroke more each time, up to eight bells and the change of watch. A seaman's four hours were spent at the wheel, on lookout in the bows, or on day work under the boatswain: chipping rust, red-leading the plates, painting, splicing, holystoning the wooden decks, battening hatches and lashing derricks before weather.

Down below was the black gang. By 1911 the men who fed the fires outnumbered the seamen who steered and painted, and a tramp's stokehold was where most of her crew worked. The firemen kept the furnaces under her boilers, and the trimmers dug coal out of the bunkers and barrowed it to the firemen's feet. They too stood four on and eight off. Heat in a stokehold ran well past what any man would choose to work in, and the air was half coal dust. Every fire had to be fed, raked and sliced, and the clinker hauled out glowing, drenched with water and sent up the ash hoist to be dumped over the side. When a ship rolled, a fireman with a full shovel had to time his swing to the roll. The trimmers, deep in the bunkers by safety lamp, worked in an air that one writer of the time said was largely gas and coal dust, and they stopped noticing their cuts and bruises. A fireman's pay was about £5 15s to £6 a month in 1913. By 1921, after the war and its bonuses, it was about £12 10s.

The food was fixed by law. The Merchant Shipping Act of 1906 laid down a weekly scale for every man: 28 quarts of water, 3 pounds of soft bread and 4 of biscuit, 3 pounds of salt beef and 2 of salt pork, 2¼ of preserved meat, 6 pounds of potatoes, peas, beans, flour, rice, oatmeal, tea, coffee, sugar, a third of a pound of condensed milk, half a pound of butter, a pound of jam or marmalade, and small, careful rations of onions, pickles, dried fruit, mustard, pepper and curry powder. The stokehold men, by the same Act, got an extra quart of water a day and oatmeal to stir into it while the ship was under steam. It was meant to put back what the fires sweated out of them.

The apprentices lived in the half-deck, a small iron room of their own, usually aft, neither forward with the men nor amidships with the officers. Indentures bound a boy to the owners for some years, with a small yearly wage, and in return the master was to teach him the business of a seaman and keep him from bad company. In practice an apprentice was the cheapest labour aboard. He stood watches with the seamen, took his trick at the wheel, scrubbed and painted, polished the bridge brass, and learned navigation by watching the mates take their sights at noon. A good master taught him. A bad one worked him. Jack, by the account of his captain, became a most capable helmsman, and helmsmen were made at the wheel, in the dark, steering by a compass card lit by a small lamp.

The war changed the rhythm. Ports were blacked out, ships steamed without lights, lookouts doubled, and men slept in their clothes. After the Armistice the lights came back on, but the mines stayed. After 1919 there was wireless as well: a small cabin with a spark set and an operator, a new kind of man aboard, who could hear the world.

Imagine the noon meal on a fair day off the coast of Spain. The cook's galley amidships, hot as an oven. The mess boy running kids of salt beef and potatoes forward along the open deck. The firemen coming up from below with towels round their necks, their eyes ringed white in black faces, to sit on the hatch in the sun. Someone always had a mouth organ. Someone always had a complaint about the biscuit. Somewhere aft, a boy of fourteen was too tired to eat.

III. Coal for Italy

Italy entered the war in May 1915 with almost no coal of her own. Her railways, her munitions works and her navy ran on fuel brought by sea, most of it from South Wales, and every ton had to come past Gibraltar and through waters that German and Austrian submarines hunted freely. Ships like the Daghestan became Italy's lifeline, and the trade that had been ordinary in peace became the most dangerous work a merchant sailor could do.

Some time between the winter of 1914 to 1915 and the 1917 to 1918 edition of Lloyd's Register, the Daghestan changed hands. Her new owners were the Rome Steam Shipping Company, with Fisher, Alimonda and Company of London as managers. The names suggest the purpose: an English and an Italian name on the brass plate, and Rome on the share certificates. What else Fisher, Alimonda did is not yet known, but their ships, the Daghestan among them, spent the war carrying coal to Italy. She kept her British flag, her port of Sunderland, and her captain. Macfarlane went with her.

The sea war changed how she sailed. By 1917 merchant ships in the Mediterranean moved in convoy, in lines behind an armed escort, every light extinguished, steering by the dim shape of the ship ahead. On the night of 12 to 13 September 1917, off the north coast of Africa, the Daghestan was in such a convoy, behind an armed French trawler, steering about due east at seven and a half knots with Port Talbot coal. Coming the other way, also blacked out, was the Cunard steamer Brescia, bound for Manchester with fruit.

The Daghestan's young third officer had the watch. Out of the dark he saw a white light, then a red one, very close: another ship's masthead and port lights, shown at the last moment. The Brescia's stem struck the Daghestan's starboard bow well forward, almost at a right angle. The reports found so far mention no deaths, and the Daghestan was soon back in her trade.

The argument went to the Admiralty Court in London, and it took two years. On 13 December 1918 Mr Justice Roche, sitting with Elder Brethren of Trinity House, found the Brescia alone to blame. He said he was satisfied with both the evidence and the demeanour of the Daghestan's third officer, a young man of intelligence. Cunard appealed. In May 1919 the Court of Appeal heard that the Brescia had acted without being sure where the other ship was, and the judgment appears to have stood. That July Cunard applied to limit its liability.

A collision trial is a strange thing for a ship's company. For two years the officers are summoned away to London to stand in a panelled room and explain, before men in wigs, what they saw in a few seconds of darkness. Every man aboard has an opinion. Every new hand who joins hears the story told again, and better.

In the middle of that trial, on 16 September 1918, a new hand did join.

IV. The Boy

His name was Lawrence John Flintoft, Laurie at home, and he was fourteen years and three months old. He was the youngest of five sons of Thomas Prudames Flintoft, a gas company clerk of Seven Kings in Essex, on the eastern edge of London. His mother had died when he was nine. His father had married again. The war had taken his brothers one by one: Bert into the air as a fighter pilot, Elton into uniform, Victor towards the sea. That August Bert had come down behind German lines in France and been posted missing, and for six weeks no one at home knew whether he was alive. Then, on 25 September, word came that he was a prisoner. By then Laurie was gone.

He joined the Daghestan as an apprentice on 16 September 1918. An apprentice was not a cabin boy. He signed indentures, a contract binding him to the owners, usually for four years, and in return he was to be taught the business of a ship: to steer, to handle lines and boats, to keep a lookout, to splice and paint and chip rust, to learn by watching the mates how a ship was navigated and cargo stowed. At the end, if he stuck it, he could sit for his second mate's ticket. It was the road by which a boy with no money became an officer.

Family memory later turned this into a runaway story: that he lied about his age and slipped off to sea. The papers say otherwise. Captain Macfarlane already knew the Flintofts. A letter in his hand, typed onto Fisher, Alimonda notepaper, tells Thomas Flintoft that "your other Boy will join me on Monday as a Cadet" and hopes that by the end of the voyage he will be "as far ahead as his Brother". The date on it is overstruck and could be 1918 or 1919. Either way, it shows a captain writing to a father about two of his sons, and pleased with the one already aboard. Victor's seaman's card rates him a cadet, and his clerk's job at the 1921 census was with Fisher, Alimonda. It is probable that both brothers sailed in her.

Imagine the boy at Barry that September: the docks a forest of masts and coal tips, the Daghestan streaked with rust from a year of war, the bosun looking down at him from the rail. Then the first night out, the ship lifting to the long Atlantic swell off Lundy, and the sick, hollow loneliness every apprentice remembers. Below in the half-deck, the iron cabin where the apprentices slept, the bulkheads sweat. Somewhere in his kit is a letter card from his brother Elton.

Within weeks the Armistice was signed. The war at sea was over. But the mines that had been laid in it were still there, moored in the dark water off every headland in the Mediterranean, waiting.

Interlude: The Minelayer

She had been built at Kiel, at the Germaniawerft yard, in the same years the Daghestan was carrying coal to Italy. She was UC 53, a minelaying submarine of the type the Germans called UC II, launched on 27 February 1917 and commissioned that April. Inside her bow were six mine tubes holding eighteen mines, each a steel sphere of explosive sitting on a heavy sinker. Dropped from a tube, the mine and its sinker went down together. On the bottom the sinker held fast, and the mine rose on its cable to a set depth just under the surface, where it waited for a keel.

She went south to the Mediterranean, where German U-boats worked from Austro-Hungarian harbours in the Adriatic, at Pola and Cattaro. In eight patrols under three commanders she is credited with forty-seven merchant ships. Her last captain, Kapitänleutnant Erich Gerth, took command on 19 June 1918.

On 3 October 1918 Gerth laid a field of mines across the northern mouth of the Strait of Messina. It was a good place to kill ships. The strait was the short road from the western Mediterranean to southern Italy, Greece, Salonika and the east, and its northern entrance narrows between Capo Peloro and the Calabrian shore, exactly where a ship must line up the lights and turn. Where the Daghestan was that day is not recorded. A boy from Seven Kings had been aboard her for seventeen days.

The war ended before the minelayer did. Austria-Hungary was falling apart. On 28 October 1918 UC 53 was scuttled at Pola, twenty-five days after she laid the field. Two weeks later came the Armistice. Church bells rang across Europe, and in the dark water off Capo Peloro the mines rode on their cables and did not hear them.

It is one of the cruelties of that war that so much of its killing was done by things that could not know it was over. Mines do not read newspapers. Clearing them took years, and in the meantime peaceful ships went on finding them.

One of Gerth's mines, by the reckoning of the naval historians, waited 105 days. (The French inquiry into what followed allowed that it might have been a stray mine torn loose by bad weather, so the attribution is probable rather than certain.)

V. The Burning Sea

In the middle of January 1919 the Daghestan was at Augusta, on the east coast of Sicily, bound, probably in ballast, for Hornillo, the ore pier near Águilas on the coast of Murcia in Spain. Her road lay north through the Strait of Messina, the narrow sleeve of water between Sicily and the toe of Italy, and no stretch of sea on her whole route carried more stories. On the night of Wednesday 15 January she was coming up through the strait in bright moonlight on a quiet sea.

Homer put two monsters here, one on each shore, in the twelfth book of the Odyssey. On the Italian side, in a cave high in the cliff, lived Scylla, with six heads on long necks, who snatched sailors from the decks of passing ships. On the Sicilian side, under a rock with a fig tree on it, lived Charybdis, who swallowed the sea three times a day and spewed it out again, and could suck down a ship whole. The channel was so narrow that to keep clear of one was to pass close to the other. Odysseus, on the witch Circe's advice, hugged Scylla's cliff and lost six men rather than risk his whole ship to the whirlpool. Sailors have said "between Scylla and Charybdis" ever since.

The monsters had real roots. Two seas meet in the strait, their tides running hard against each other, and off the Sicilian point the currents still throw up whirlpools that Messina fishermen call the garofalo. The rocky Calabrian shore by the little town of Scilla needed no monster to wreck a ship. And the strait had a ghost of its own, the Fata Morgana: on still, hot days a mirage lifts the far shore into the air, so that towers and palaces seem to stand on the water. Medieval legend blamed the enchantress Morgan le Fay, King Arthur's sister, who was said to have made her home in these parts. In Messina itself they told of Colapesce, a fisherman's son who swam so far and so deep that he never came back, and who is down there still, they say, holding up the column on which Sicily rests. The city was named twice. The Greeks who settled it called it Zancle, the sickle, for the curved spit of sand that makes its harbour. In the fifth century BC a tyrant from across the strait filled it with refugees from Messenia in Greece and renamed it for them, and Messene, in time, became Messina.

On the night of the disaster both monsters' homes were lit. Captain Calviès of the Chaouia sighted the Scilla light at ten o'clock, on Scylla's shore. At midnight he made his turn by the light on Capo Peloro at Faro, the point tradition gives to Charybdis. The mine lay between them.

Coming the other way was the Chaouia, a French liner of 4,334 tons, built at Flushing in 1896 as the Dutch mail steamer Koningin Wilhelmina. Her French owners renamed her for the Chaouia, the plain of Atlantic Morocco behind Casablanca. The name is usually taken from the Arabic for its people, and is said to mean the shepherds. A Dutch queen had become a plain of shepherds. She was bound from Marseille for Piraeus with something like 650 or 700 people aboard. Most were Greek emigrants going home after the war, with Serbians and Russians, and among the cabin passengers a party of diplomats. Her captain, Calviès, had picked up the Scilla light at ten o'clock. At midnight he lined up the Pezzo and Faro lights to make his turn south into the strait, and in his report he set down a small, ordinary observation: a steamer could be seen some way off, passing up through the strait to the north. That steamer was the Daghestan.

Ten minutes later the Chaouia struck a mine. It had been laid the previous October by the German submarine UC 53, one of many still moored off the coasts of Italy two months after the fighting stopped. The explosion tore open her bow. Passengers were in their bunks, a few still in the saloon. A survivor said the ship reared up, dipped her head and was gone, all in one dreadful minute. By every account she sank in three or four minutes, and there was no time to launch more than a few boats and rafts.

The Daghestan heard the explosion and the liner's siren. Macfarlane turned her towards the place at full speed, firing rockets to rouse Messina, and stopped upwind of the wreckage. Then he put every boat he had into the water: the two lifeboats, the cutter, the dinghy. His own words, given to a reporter at Barry six weeks later, are the best we have: "The Chaouia carried a large cargo of oil, and the sea blazed with it. That greatly retarded our work of rescue."

What the boats found is not something any record describes kindly. Burning oil spread on the water among the wreckage. Survivors clung to rafts and spars, coated in black fuel. One raft, crowded with people, was drawn into the sinking liner's still-turning propeller and smashed, and those on it vanished. The Daghestan took survivors aboard all night, and the dead as well, as her boats and the Chaouia's rafts brought them in.

Jack Flintoft told his grandson, for the rest of his life, about that night. He said the oil made people so slippery that they could not be held by the hair, so the boat crews grabbed them by the ears instead. He said that once, reaching for a man in the water, he took him by the ears and lifted, and found that it was only a head. No record names the men in the Daghestan's boats. But nothing shows that the boy left the ship between September 1918 and December 1920, and every detail of his account that can be checked matches what the captains and the newspapers wrote.

He was fourteen and a half. In the moonlight, with the oil burning on the swell and men screaming in four languages, he would have been at an oar or in the bow of a boat with a boathook, because that was what apprentices were for. Afterwards, on deck, there would have been the dead laid out under canvas, and the survivors wrapped in blankets in the saloon and the half-deck and anywhere there was room. Nobody would have slept.

At about eight in the morning the Daghestan came into Messina and landed her survivors to the Italian Red Cross. Captain Calviès, who had been hauled half-drowned onto a raft by one of his officers, counted about 180 of them saved by the British ship; the Rome wire said about 150. French figures later gave 184 survivors in all and 476 dead. The French inquiry criticised Messina for not sending out its motor launches. Through the long hours before dawn, the rescue had rested on the boats of one Sunderland tramp.

Macfarlane received letters of thanks from the French ambassador in Rome, the Board of Trade, the Chaouia's owners and his own, and in March the French Ministry of Marine gave him a silver-gilt medal. Calviès recommended him, "and the officers and crew of the Daghestan", for awards. In May 1919 Lloyd's List reported a presentation to the captain. If the boy was in those boats, as he said he was, he was one of a crew officially thanked by France.

VI. The Last English Years

A ship does not stop for grief. By April 1919 the Daghestan was loading ore at Hornillo, and Lloyd's List tracks her through the spring and summer like a pin moving on a chart: past Gibraltar westbound on 10 April, in a British port by about the 19th, out of Barry on 19 May for Taranto, chartered for 6,200 tons of ore from Almería to Newport in June, off Barry Island on 10 July. The same movement lists show the Swedish steamer Consul Bratt passing Barry Island on those days, and that year her owners went to the Admiralty Court against the Consul Bratt's. What that second case was about is still unknown.

On 9 July 1919, far from any of this, Jack's brother Elton was killed in a crash near Marseille, the city the Chaouia had sailed from. The war had been over for eight months. Jack believed for the rest of his life that the Germans had shot Elton down. The records say otherwise, but it is not hard to see why a boy who had pulled the dead from a burning sea might need his brother's death to mean something.

The ship changed around him. The register for 1919 to 1920 shows that she now carried wireless, a new thing in a tramp. Late in 1919 Macfarlane gave up the command he had held since she was new, and Captain Charles P. Lenton took his place. In August 1920 Lenton wrote to Thomas Flintoft that "your Boy has bucked up wonderfully well". Whatever Messina had done to him, the boy had found his feet.

In November 1920 she came to grief herself. Arriving at Torre Annunziata, under Vesuvius on the Bay of Naples, with cargo from Rotterdam, her rudder jammed and she struck the breakwater, damaging her cargo. It was a small accident, but she was eight years old, worked hard through a war, and the market for ships like her was about to fall off a cliff.

Torre Annunziata was a strange place for a collier to bump her nose. Under its streets, still unexcavated then, lay the Roman town of Oplontis, buried by Vesuvius in AD 79 on the same day as Pompeii, three miles off. Its great villa is thought to have belonged to Poppaea Sabina, the second wife of the emperor Nero. Within weeks the Daghestan would be sold to Italy and renamed Antium, after the seaside town where Nero was born. It is the kind of coincidence a novelist would be ashamed to use.

The postwar boom had sent freight rates and ship prices soaring in 1919 and early 1920. By late 1920 it was collapsing, and owners who could sell were selling. The Daghestan was sold to Italy. On 22 December 1920, at Barry Dock, Captain Lenton wrote a certificate for his apprentice, and it is the finest thing anyone ever wrote about the boy: that "L.J. Flintoft joined this steamer Sept: 16th 1918 as an apprentice", that he had been "most attentive obliging and anxious to learn, a most capable helmsman and most reliable", and that "his indentures are cancelled on account of the steamer being transferred to another flag".

So the boy walked down the gangway at Barry with a canvas bag and a typed letter, sixteen years old, and went home to Seven Kings. The ship he left behind would never fly the red ensign under that name again. He would never sail in her again, and he would never stop talking about her.

The 1921 census found him at 100 Lansdowne Road, an apprentice in the merchant service, out of work. In August he and Victor sailed for Melbourne on the Euripides.

VII. Eight Names

Ships outlive the people who first sail them, and they do it by changing their names, the way an old house changes hands and gets a new brass plate on the gate. The Daghestan had thirty years ahead of her, and she would spend them under names that read like a history of southern Europe between the wars.

Sailors would have shaken their heads. Of all the superstitions of the sea, few were held more firmly than that renaming a ship brings bad luck. The old belief was that every vessel is entered by name in the ledger of the sea god, and that a ship which changes her name without due ceremony has slipped out of his book and must be found again. Some owners held small rites of de-naming, with every trace of the old name scraped off before the new one was painted on. Whether anyone did so for the Daghestan, no record says. She was renamed seven times. The reader may judge for themselves whether the sea god noticed.

Antium, 1920. Her first Italian name was the old Roman name for Anzio, the little port south of Rome where Nero was born. Her buyers, as the family history has it, were the Italian State Railways, who needed colliers of their own to feed their locomotives with British coal. She was registered at La Spezia. A Lloyd's telegram of June 1922 asks for fresh freeboard certificates for her under this name.

Bainsizza, 1923. The name was a battle. In August and September 1917 the Italian army had stormed the Bainsizza plateau above the Isonzo river, one of the few clear gains of their long, bloody war in the mountains, bought with tens of thousands of lives. Two months later came the rout at Caporetto. To name a ship Bainsizza in 1923, the year after Mussolini's march on Rome, was to remember the victory and forget what came after. Her owners were a Genoese firm.

Alberto Fassio, 1924. Then she passed to Villain and Fassio, a Genoese shipping house, and took a name that appears to honour one of the Fassio family. A Lloyd's freeboard form of 9 September 1924 calls her "Alberto Fassio ex Bainsizza".

Essex Judge, 1927 to 1928. In December 1927 she was back in London, dry-docked so that surveyors could check the freeboard marks on her hull, now named Essex Judge and returned to the British flag. Through the depression years she seems to have tramped again under the red ensign, though little of her trade in those years has been traced. In December 1932 she was surveyed for freeboard once more. Her owners appear in one source as an Essex transport and trading company.

Thorpehaven, 1938. By the spring of 1938 she had a new name and a dangerous new purpose. Spain had been at war with itself since July 1936. Franco's Nationalists, armed by Germany and Italy, were strangling the Republic by land and sea, and the Republic needed food. A handful of small London companies, often run by Greek shipowners, bought old tramps cheaply and sent them into Republican ports for high freights and higher risks. The Thorpehaven belonged to one of them, a fleet whose ships all carried the name Thorpe: Thorpebay, Thorpehall, Thorpeness, Thorpehaven. Sources disagree on the company's exact name, but they agree on one of its founders, Basil Pandelis, and on its purpose. Three of the four would be lost in the Spanish war.

There is a kind of irony in it that a ship built to carry coal for the Italian war effort should end up running grain to a hungry Spanish city past bombers that were often flown by Italians. Ships do not choose their causes.

VIII. Alicante

In June 1938 Alicante was one of the last great ports left to the Spanish Republic, and it was bombed again and again from the air. Ships lying in the harbour were easy targets. On the night of 7 to 8 June 1938 the Thorpehaven was in port with a cargo of grain when the bombers came.

Above Alicante harbour rises Mount Benacantil, and on it the castle of Santa Bárbara, named for the saint on whose day, 4 December 1248, the Castilians took it. Saint Barbara, by an old tradition, is the patron of gunners, miners and all who work with explosives, and the protector against sudden death by fire from the sky. In June 1938 she looked down on a harbour where fire fell from the sky almost nightly.

We have the words of a Spanish official, read aloud in the House of Commons on 21 June by the Labour member Philip Noel-Baker, who was pressing the government over British ships being sunk in Spanish ports. The telegram said: "I manifest you by my honour that English steamer Thorpehaven attacked with bombs in the night of 7th and 8th transported 5,900 tons of corn which this Ministry has to distribute between the rationed civil Spanish people." Spanish sources give the cargo as about 4,700 tons of wheat. Either way, she was carrying bread for a rationed city, and the bombs went into her.

The damage was mortal for the time being. A hole seven metres by six opened in her starboard side, into the engine room and number three hold, and she settled in the shallows near the port. The war went on around her for ten more months. Alicante was the last Republican port to fall, at the end of March 1939, and its quays saw some of the war's saddest scenes, thousands of refugees waiting for ships that never came.

For a year the old Sunderland hull lay in the harbour mud with her wheat swelling and rotting in the flooded hold. Gulls on the funnel. Her life, it seemed, was over.

It was not. When the war ended, Franco's new state set its navy to salvage every hull it could, because Spain had lost much of its merchant fleet and could not afford to buy another. In the summer of 1939 a naval salvage commission found her stranded near the port. Divers fitted a patch shaped to the hole, the pumps emptied her, and she floated again. The Lloyd's note says she was refloated on 25 September 1939; the Spanish commission's report gives 27 September; one Spanish history gives an earlier date, in May. Her ruined grain was sold for fertiliser, animal feed and starch.

She was handed to the state shipping office, the Gerencia de Buques Mercantes, on 25 October 1939, towed to Bilbao and repaired at the Euskalduna yard at a cost of 365,087 pesetas and 85 céntimos. On 20 December 1939 Lloyd's recorded a new name: Castillo Aliaga.

IX. Castillo Guadalest, and the End

The new Spanish state named its salvaged ships after castles, and in 1941 she took the last name she would carry: Castillo Guadalest. Guadalest is a castle on a crag in the mountains of Alicante province, perhaps forty kilometres from the harbour where the bombs had found her. Whoever chose the name may not have known that. It is pleasant to think that someone did.

She was leased to the Aznar line of Bilbao in November 1941, and in 1943 passed to the new state shipping company, the Empresa Nacional Elcano, still sailing for Aznar. Spain was neutral in the Second World War, though hungry and poor, and a neutral steamer could go where belligerents could not. It is in these years that someone photographed her, steaming through a flat sea with CASTILLO GUADALEST painted large on her side, as neutral ships did then so that submarines and aircraft would know her. The picture survives, credited to the Gerencia de Buques Mercantes. The hull, the bridge, the masts are the ones drawn on the blueprint in 1911. It is the only photograph we have of the ship Jack sailed in.

She was old now. A steamer built for twenty or twenty-five years' work had passed her thirtieth birthday, then her thirty-fifth, still coal-fired, still making her eight knots, in a world of diesel tankers and wartime Liberty ships. In August 1951 she was crossing from Bilbao to Boston with about 4,700 tons of iron ingots, a heavy cargo for an old hull. On 23 August, during a routine round, the crew found water in number two hold.

They started the pumps at about ten that night, and the water gained on them. They passed a collision mat under the hull, a great square of canvas hauled over the leak from outside, the oldest remedy at sea, and the hold went on filling. On the evening of the 24th, some 600 miles out from Bermuda, her captain sent a signal that the leak could not be stopped with the ship's own resources, and asked for immediate assistance. At 20.40 he ordered her abandoned.

About forty Spanish seamen went into the boats, and with them a stowaway who had slipped aboard at Bilbao. They did not row away. They lay off in the boats near their ship and waited. Some four hours later a Liberty ship under the Honduran flag, the Eurystheus, came up and took them all aboard. Her name was a Greek king's. Eurystheus was the king who set Hercules his twelve labours. The Daghestan had first gone into the Mediterranean between the Pillars of Hercules; at the very end, a ship named for Hercules' taskmaster took her last crew off the sea. Then, from her deck, they watched the Castillo Guadalest through the night. At about half past eight the next morning she went down. Her positions as given vary a little between sources, but put her grave in deep water in the western North Atlantic, a long way south-east of Nova Scotia.

No one died. The Eurystheus landed the crew at Philadelphia on 28 August, and three days later they sailed home to Spain in the liner Habana.

There is something fitting in it. The ship that had once lowered her boats to wait in the dark for other people's survivors ended with her own crew in their boats, waiting in the dark beside her, until a stranger came. She went down without killing anyone, after thirty-nine years. Not many ships can say as much.

Epilogue: What Remains

Of the ship herself, nothing remains that anyone could touch, except perhaps some rust in deep water south-east of Nova Scotia, and the iron ingots she was carrying to Boston. What remains is paper, and the paper is enough.

There is the blueprint, still blue, still marked No. 373 and 375. There is the surveyor's report from Sunderland in 1912, with its column of visiting dates and its note that the materials and workmanship were good. There are the registers, each year's entry a line of tiny type that tells you her owner, her master and whether she had wireless. There is a French captain's report that mentions, ten minutes before disaster, a steamer passing up through the strait to the north. There is a telegram read out in the House of Commons about 5,900 tons of corn. There is a single photograph of an old ship under her last name, steaming through a calm sea in a neutral war.

And there is a typed sheet of copied letters, kept in a family box in Australia for a century, in which one captain hopes a boy will be "as far ahead as his Brother", and his successor says the boy has "bucked up wonderfully well", and then writes, at Barry Dock in the week before Christmas 1920, that he was most attentive, obliging and anxious to learn, a most capable helmsman, and most reliable.

The boy went to Australia. He cut timber in the Otways and cane in Queensland, worked boats and camel trains in the north-west, laid moorings for flying boats at Carnarvon, married, raised a family and sailed a boat called Susan on Lake Colac. He grew old at Apollo Bay. And he told his grandson about the night the sea burned, and about the ship.

Picture where that telling happened: on a blustery day at Apollo Bay, within reach of the Monterey cypresses that lean and gnarl along that coast, planted everywhere on the Great Ocean Road as a break against the same Southern Ocean wind that first carried Jack to sea. Imported from a single wind-battered headland in California barely a mile or two wide, the tree had crossed the world to do here exactly what it did at home: stand bent and permanent against the weather. Jack told it like a man handing over something he had carried a long way, and in a sense he had.

Most ships are forgotten the day they sink. This one was remembered for seventy years by a man who sailed in her for two, and that is a kind of survival too.

Write back to Chris

Enjoyed it, remembered something, or spotted a mistake? Reply by email. A line or two is plenty.

Email Chris

Sources and evidence grades

Most of what is told here is DOCUMENTED. The pieces that are less certain:

Point Grade Note
Jack in the Daghestan's boats at Messina PROBABLE No record names the boat crews; no break in his service is recorded
Victor also in the Daghestan PROBABLE Macfarlane's "Cadet" letter, year overstruck; seaman's card
Brescia appeal upheld PROBABLE Full 24 May 1919 report not yet read
Antium's buyer, Italian State Railways PROBABLE Ship histories; one gives the railway company under a modern name
Owners 1923 to 1938 PROBABLE Secondary histories; LR freeboard papers confirm the names and dates
Thorpehaven's owning company UNRESOLVED Westcliff Shipping or Thameside Shipping; Pandelis named in both
Cargo at Alicante UNRESOLVED 5,900 tons of corn (Spanish telegram, Hansard) or 4,700 tons of wheat (Spanish histories)
Refloating date UNRESOLVED 25 Sep 1939 (Lloyd's), 27 Sep 1939 (salvage commission), May 1939 (one history)
The 1951 loss PROBABLE Spanish histories, from Elcano's own records; Lloyd's List not yet seen

Records and pages used:

General history (Italy's coal, the Isonzo battles, the fall of Alicante, Spanish neutrality) is background knowledge, not checked against a single source for this piece.

Daily life aboard: Merchant Shipping Act 1906, First Schedule, scale of provisions; Seafarers under steam, Maritime History Archive, Memorial University (crew make-up, firemen's watches and pay in 1913 and 1921); Coal at sea, Lloyd's Register Foundation (bunkers and trimmers, quoting Frank Bullen, 1899). The myths and place histories (Homer, the Fata Morgana, Colapesce, Bede, Oplontis, Santa Bárbara, sailors' superstitions) are general knowledge, told as legend, and not checked against a single source for this piece.

The minelayer: SM UC-53 (builder, dates, mine tubes, commanders, ships sunk, scuttling at Pola); uboat.net, Chaouia (mine laid 3 October 1918 by UC 53 under Erich Gerth; position 38°18'N 15°41'E). The French inquiry's doubt is from the Pages 14-18 forum, as recorded in the project's Chaouia file.

Crew lists, 1915: Royal Museums Greenwich, Crew List: Agreements and Official Logs for Ship Daghestan, ON 132070, RSS/CL/1915/3915/14, /15 and /16 (Macfarlane's age and birthplace; crew origins). Dagestan background: Derbent and Shamil, Britannica.

Want to see more?

The rest of the family archive, with its people, photographs, letters and records, is kept for family and friends. Ask Chris and he will add your email. You then sign in with a one-time code sent to that address.

Ask for access